- 在線時間
- 1504 小時
- 最後登錄
- 20-9-15
- 國民生產力
- 8799
- 附加生產力
- 33165
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 08-11-1
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 4484
- 主題
- 167
- 精華
- 1
- 積分
- 46448
- UID
- 226763
  
|
After one night of rest to allow my mind to refresh, the first explanation I would feel I owe the members is that it seems many of you are quite sensitive to the situation when a member's account is being banned (w/o day limit). I think I have not been considerate enough to sit in your shoes to look at it from a purely member angle. I feel the situation now has been interpreted as a permanent account ban.
I do remember I have explained clearly on the status update concerning each members' status. Except for the case of Shoeshine with a previous account ban record, the two other accounts are simply under review. Is this because there hasn't been a day limit set for the ban so the members would see it as a permanent ban, which in that case, all the posts by certain members will be gone forever? Since it appears to me the concerns are the loss of previous valuable comments by certain members.
In order to address the members' concern, I am willing to review my handling method and also share what has and going to happen, so we can all improve in the future communication. However, I do not intend to enter into lengthy unnecessary discussions/ debates with members on specific arrangement. So, please do not expect me to answer your queries one by one.
So here is what I can do for now and why:
(1) For the case of the problematic thread "本港教師 質素, 失望!!!", there are at least three 超版 who has started to undergo review on this thread. Besides the posts by motherotk which require our attention, we have also found at least one other violation by other members. Please do understand it is a very time consuming process, in order to check against a lot of information. It is under our current estimation that we will need more than a week to complete. As a result of that, the ban on motherotk will be set to 14 days. Due to our internal procedure where it is not allowed for member to use another account to continue posting during account ban, it has been suggested and concurred by at least two 超版 to also ban the account mothertk1.
Concerning how much of the comments by motherotk can be saved, may I suggest the concerned member to PM me directly to further discuss? If the member is willing to do so, one of the possibility is we can provide a time limit for the members to revise their own posts according to the forum standard. If he/she fails to do so, then we will have to remove all of them. However, please be reminded this can only be done after we have finished investigating on the other violations on that particular thread.
(2) For the case of judy's account, it was banned after the review by at least three 超版. The comment made has shown disrespect to one of the 超版 during the post. As a result of that, it was also confirmed by these three 超版 that the account will be banned for 14 days as a penalty. At the same time, legal advices are being seeked concerning the contents so this is why I mentioned there was a legal review before. I was being careless to combine these two situations together so please accept my apology on that. There are no specific allegations being made so let's also make this clear.
(3) For Shoeshine's case, actually I have limited knowledge of the background of the previous banned account. However, we do not intend to change the policy at the moment concerning previous account which are being banned permanently.
I think this should be sufficient and there won't be further explanation on details. All along the actions being taken so far has been a collective effort, so I didn't take any actions without seeking further comments from at least two more 超版. However, we do not intend to invite members to provide objective inputs concerning how these rulings are being made.
Further comments regarding this will be considered as improper. No warnings will be given and members' account will be banned immediately starting with one-day penalty, on incremental basis if the situation persists.
Finally, similar handling will be used concerning similar (not all) suspected cases of forum rules regulations, until further notice. When 版主 notice such situations, the member's account will be banned initially for 1-3 days so to allow further review. Normally these situation would have involved more than a single comments by a member, plus any other members replies in response to those comments being initiated. A key reason why this is required, is to protect the completeness of the concerned posts during the review. Unfortunately there are limited functionality which can be used to achieve such purpose, so it has been chosen to done so for the time being. |
|
發表於 11-10-17 02:58
