用戶登入
用戶名稱:
密      碼:
搜索
教育王國 討論區 資優教育 資優可以訓練的嗎?
發新帖
查看: 4570|回覆: 13
go

資優可以訓練的嗎? [複製鏈接]

Rank: 4


910
1#
發表於 04-11-5 13:26 |只看該作者

資優可以訓練的嗎?

資優是天生的還是訓練的成果?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


478
2#
發表於 04-11-5 15:19 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

Genes and environment interact at every step of brain development, but they play very different roles. Generally speaking, genes are responsible for the basic wiring plan--for forming all of the cells (neurons) and general connections between different brain regions--while experience is responsible for fine-tuning those connections, helping each child adapt to the particular environment (geographical, cultural, family, school, peer-group) to which he belongs. An analogy that is often used is wiring a phone network: genes would specify the number of phones and the major trunk lines that connect one relay station to the next. Experience would specify the finer branches of this network-the connections between the relay station and each person's home or office.

For example, each of us is born with the potential to learn language. Our brains are programmed to recognize human speech, to discriminate subtle differences between individual speech sounds, to put words and meaning together, and to pick up the grammatical rules for ordering words in sentences. However, the particular language each child masters, the size of his vocabulary, and the exact dialect and accent with which he speaks are determined by the social environment in which he is raised--that is, the thousands of hours he has spent (beginning even before birth) listening and speaking to others. Genetic potential is necessary, but DNA alone cannot teach a child to talk.

In spite of all the recent hype about "making your baby smarter," scientists have not discovered any special tricks for enhancing the natural wiring phase in children's brain development. Normal, loving, responsive caregiving seems to provide babies with the ideal environment for encouraging their own exploration, which is always the best route to learning.

The one form of stimulation that has been proven to make a difference is language: infants and children who are conversed with, read to, and otherwise engaged in lots of verbal interaction show somewhat more advanced linguistic skills than children who are not as verbally engaged by their caregivers. Because language is fundamental to most of the rest of cognitive development, this simple action--talking and listening to your child--is one of the best ways to make the most of his or her critical brain-building years.

Rank: 3Rank: 3


180
3#
發表於 04-11-5 18:36 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

Dear Critic

May I offer I view on what you stated in this section:

The discussion relating to whether gifted child comes from nature or nurture has been around for a long time.  

However, recent studies have confirmed that while defective gene would detrimentally affect the development of a child, a child with all healthy gene starts off from the same point.  It is only our lack of understanding that mis-categorise factors that influence the intelligence level of a child.

I agree most definitely that "environment interact at every step of brain development", but disagree with you that "genes are responsible for the basic wiring plan--for forming all of the cells (neurons) and general connections between different brain regions".  

Dr. Sarah Brewer, Brent Logan, Glenn Doman from the United States and another scientists (forgot his name) from Russia have all confirmed that the basic wiring plan is influenced by the stimulation that a child in the womb receives. A nurture factor and not a nature factor.

To attribute the wiring of cells to generic attributes is something that has been proven to be wrong by neuro-scientists.

A child learns by repetition at an early stage and each of them can learn anything that is taught to them in a fun and joyous way.  

Genes is only influencial only to the extent whether it is fully functional or defective.  If it is not defective, then all of us have an equal start.

To believe otherwise (as far as intelligence is concerned) is just an excuse for under-performance.  There is no Albert Einstein gene.  We have only found that he utilised a larger section of his brain.  Zhou Zhou, a famous music conductor was born a retard but he made great achievements in the music world.  What gene does he have?  A music gene??

I like the slogan "Never too young to start learning".

DBBoy

Rank: 5Rank: 5


2324
4#
發表於 04-11-5 20:08 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

DBBoy 寫道:
...another scientists (forgot his name) from Russia have all confirmed that the basic wiring plan is influenced by the stimulation that a child in the womb receives. A nurture factor and not a nature factor.


Could that Russian scientist be Vygotsky or his student, Luria? I personally 100% agree that it's difficult, if not impossible, to distinguish between nature and nurture.

In fact an Israel psychologist has developed a programme loosely based on Vygotskian theory and claiming the thru it even retarded students could achieve some kind of success. He's called Feuerstein and the programme is "Instrumental Enrichment. " Feuerstein also wrote a book called "Don't Accept Me as I am: Helping 'Retarded' Person to Excel."

Rank: 3Rank: 3


180
5#
發表於 04-11-6 04:41 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

The name of the scientist is Mikhail Lazarev, M.D., Chief Physician of Children's Rehabilitation Center 1992-1995, Institute for Professional Educators 1996-1997.  His address is Salam-Adila, 5-38
Moscow, Russia 123448.  

He is the person who did the clinical trial for Babyplus.  I got his name from a Brent Logan book that I read.

For the reasons as I have stated, if a gene has no defects, there is no good gene or bad gene, just parents who offer a child a good environment or a bad environment.

DBBoy

Rank: 3Rank: 3


187
6#
發表於 04-11-6 22:58 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

wai, very professional speaking..... to me, I don't think children can be trained as資優

Rank: 3Rank: 3


180
7#
發表於 04-11-9 00:56 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

On a matter as serious as this one, what we think is not important.  What we do to search for proof and guidance is what we should do.  

As adults, what we do and don't do affects the upbringing of our child.  On this issue, I have spoken at length to Mrs. Ho of KinderU and she gave me a number of examples and also referred me to many books on the subject (Mainly Doman).  I agree with her that we must not assess the abilities of our child based on how we were brought up or our memory of our schooling.  Much has changed since then (Talking to Mrs. Ho is enlightening if you belong to the early learning camp).  

Who could imagine taking a baby to be taught music, languages at the age of three months and expecting results of anykind.  Two or three years ago, anykind of thoughts like this would seem crazy to me.  However, seeing these babies enjoying what they are doing and showing that they can comprehend what the teachers said (at the age of 4 months) forced me to take off my cap and salute their intelligence.

DBBoy

Rank: 4


910
8#
發表於 04-11-12 13:55 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

資優的英文是gifted,如果是gifted, 似乎是天賜的,如果是天生,後期訓練又可幫到幾多?

現在人人也提倡早期教育, 但一歲可以說出26個字母和三歲才懂,又有甚麼分別?

有沒有人可以講吓妳的教育理念?

Rank: 3Rank: 3


343
9#
發表於 04-11-12 20:11 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

天生 的

Rank: 3Rank: 3


180
10#
發表於 04-11-13 16:03 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

The answer to "資優可以訓練的嗎?" is a definite YES!!  

The point is whether the "opportunity costs" is justified and who actual pays the opportunity costs.  What is the motive behind so doing???

A person can train for Olympics to glorify their country, to bring honour to the family or become a movie star of "Emperor Group".  

I want my child to speak four languages by seven so he will never worry about making a living, he will have friends from all corners of the Earth.

I want may child to swim because I want him to be tall and healthy and have good lungs so he brings more oxygen to his little body.

I want him to learn to read by three so his knowledge will only be limited to what books there are at the Library or at home.

I want him to learn Kung Fu so he can promote this Chinese National Art to people all over the world and be proud to be Chinese.  He can also be a Kung Fu master when he gets to University and win the respect of his peers.

I want him to be good at a music instrument so he can pay for his own studies unlike his Dad who needed to work as a waiter and have something that he can appreciate and enjoy even when he grows old.

Dear parents, examine your motives.  Always keep the welling being of your child at the number one place and enjoy your time with them.  Do not get over zealous over grades, marks and IQ

Rank: 3Rank: 3


125
11#
發表於 04-11-14 10:53 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?


現在人人也提倡早期教育, 但一歲可以說出26個字母和三歲才懂,又有甚麼分別?



Totally agree!!!!!!!

Isaac Newton, Albert Einstein & Hawking Stephen都無接受過早期教育,但佢地智商高達200!!!!!

Rank: 3Rank: 3


125
12#
發表於 04-11-14 12:21 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

yyyy
我的想法與你相似,資優是天賦。

人類在出生時,腦袋內所儲有的腦細胞數目及腦部的型態,足以影響那人於日後的成就。

所謂早期教育、後天培養,其實只能為孩子打好學習基礎,幫助他們發揮�開發已有的腦細胞。但,此舉並不能增加腦細胞的數量改善及其生長型態,所以,上述已說明,早期教育及後天培養並不能打造資優(天才)。

作為家長,我的教育理念是讓孩子在愉快及良好的氣氛下學習,發掘他的興趣,加以培養。我想,灌輸做人處世的經驗及應有的正確態度,比任何東西都來得重要。

還有,假如小孩真正資優,其實早於微時經已有跡可尋。根本不需要刻意發拓。

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


11241
13#
發表於 04-11-14 13:02 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

性格係根據環境,待遇...............而從少慢慢形成的,我諗唔多唔少都會多一份自信心的

唔知哈佛劉亦婷果本書

Rank: 3Rank: 3


302
14#
發表於 04-11-15 12:52 |只看該作者

Re: 資優可以訓練的嗎?

現今教育界普遍認同以多元智能理念去界定資優生的特性,資優生是可以在不同的領域突顯其資優的特質。比方說,有些資優生會比同齡的學生有較高的智商(IQ=〉130),或在學業上有卓越的表現,或有傑出的領導才能;另一些可能在其他方面,如藝術上或運動上有優越的表現。其中傳統智能(數理、語言智能)是可以量化的,測驗量度方式亦經過幾十年的應用,廣爲認同和採納;其他包括視覺空間智能(Spatial intelligence)、音樂智能(Musical Intelligence)、身體運動智能(Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence)、人際關係智能(Interpersonal Intelligence)及個人內省智能(Intra-personal Intelligence).及自然智能(Naturalist Intelligence)暫時未有普遍認可的測量方式及標準,還靠老師、家長的細心觀察。

資優=成績好?成功?富有?幸福?
答案是:NO!
雖然資優被定為130或以上,但絕不等於資優生一定與成功、富有、甚至幸福等同。資優(gifted),按有神論者的話講就是上帝的賦予,對社會來説是一筆天然資產。做家長的是要好好利用它,是他們成材,為人類做出更多的貢獻。他們天資聰穎,理解迅速,思維敏銳(在某一領域尤其突出)。有這樣的基礎,引導他們努力向上,再有良師(未必名師)指引,就會有所成就。而所謂家長指導,就是在EQ,FQ等方面留意小朋友的發展,使他們在成就之前首先“成人”。否則,天資用錯地方,或受情緒困擾,對家庭來講就是負擔,對社會就是一種浪費,甚至負債。

了解資優:
資 優 使 心 智 與 生 理 年 齡 的 發 展 產 生 不 同 步 , 由 於 與 生 俱 來 的 卓 越 認 知 能 力 及 強 烈 的 內 心 反 應 造 成 內 在 經 驗 及 醒 覺 性 與 眾 不 同 , 智 能 越 高 , 不 協 調 的 程 度 就 越 顯 明 •

資 優 的 獨 特 性 會 令 資 優 人 士 的 處 境 更 脆 弱 , 所 以 在 管 教 , 學 習 及 輔 導 他 們 時 更 顧 及 這 種 不 協 調 發 展 的 特 徵 來 訂 定 改 善 的 目 標 , 才 能 幫 助 他 們 得 到 最 佳 的 發 展 •

由於資優兒童的「成長時間表」可能跟其他小孩不同,在一般成長和學習環境中不一定會如普遍人所預期般成就特出,甚至可能出現困難。
他們也有和普通孩子一樣的須要。

他們也需要在以下幾方面的關心和照顧:

健康
情緒及社交
學習需要
心靈的渴求
作獨特貢獻

若資優孩子未及早被評估,他們的資優特性易被誤解, 培育方法亦未必切合他們的需要, 因而容易做成缺乏自我認識和自信不足。 由此可導致親子或帥友關係出現問題, 生活欠成功感 。



‹ 上一主題|下一主題