- 在線時間
- 34 小時
- 最後登錄
- 21-10-18
- 國民生產力
- 13
- 附加生產力
- 178
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 08-1-20
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 122
- 主題
- 16
- 精華
- 0
- 積分
- 313
- UID
- 176853
|
See my comment:
1. *Go to DBS or similar top-tier secondary school - APS Wins (Mainly due to music achievement. Also, YW students seldom apply DBS.)
2. *Go to band 1 secondary school rate - YW Wins (YW students 100% go to Ying Wa College which is band 1)
3. *Popularity - YW Wins (That means, more parents select YW, more smarter students go there.)
4. *Through-train benefit - YW Wins (Parents usually don't want to play the "game" once more in P6. Note that YW started through-train in 9/2008 and these students are studying P3 now. Current Ying Wa College result doesn't represent through-train result. There is a boost of academic result when they go to secondary school.)
5. *School fee - YW Wins (YW $1500, APS $3xxx)
6. Music - APS Wins (But YW is high level)
7. Sports - YW Wins
8. Easiness of interview - APS Wins (APS 1 round + result about one month but YW 3 rounds + result about 5 months, most stringent interview I ever knew.)
9. Smart students - YW (Due to stringent interview, balanced development of arts & sports, observations from other parents comment in internet and most my personal feeling)
10. School life - YW Wins (12 years school life and relationship with teachers and friends is amazing)
11. Space - YW Wins (APS is small)
12. Activity - YW Wins (YW has many activities tailored for boys)
13. School fit for boys - YW Wins (YW groups boys together)
14. Transportation - YW Wins (Near Nam Cheong MTR station)
15. District - APS Wins if you want to play the "game" again in P6.
Note:
1. From my observation, parents had main concern to factors marked with "*".
2. Some parents had concern to single sex environment in YW.
3. Some parents had concern to compulsory music course in APS.
4. I tried to be fair but there might exist my personal tendency.
Finally, I recommend parents have to find an appropriate level of school best fit your kid's ability and interest.
[ 本帖最後由 TY3388 於 11-7-18 13:34 編輯 ] |
|