有無小朋友憑宗教分考到好學校呀?

toystory

stccmc,

"Is this advantage fair?"
For such an "abstruse" question, I think u never can get a direct answer (Yes or No) ...

roader-A has answered u quite directly, but I'm sorry I am not smart enough to understand our government's good intention.

阿十

首先請讓我申報利益:
1. 我是某超級名校old boy
2. 我是5分宗教分的得益者
3. 我住在超級名校區
我都想同比大家討論一下公平的問題,我經常很自豪地對我的兒子說起,我曾經為我的母校很努力地贏取了很多學界運動會的獎牌....我其實是想讓大家知道名校之所以歷久不變地仍然係名校,除了因為師資優良,辦學理念高尚外,最重要是有一群勤奮及熱誠的學生,無論過去及現在,不斷地為學校及個人爭取在學業,運動及各方面的優良成就,從而使我們的母校發光發亮.在學校有需要時,例如校舍擴建籌

阿十

首先請讓我申報利益:
1. 我是某超級名校old boy
2. 我是5分宗教分的得益者
3. 我住在超級名校區
我都想同比大家討論一下公平的問題,我經常很自豪地對我的兒子說起,我曾經為我的母校很努力地贏取了很多學界運動會的獎牌....我其實是想讓大家知道名校之所以歷久不變地仍然係名校,除了因為師資優良,辦學理念高尚外,最重要是有一群勤奮及熱誠的學生,無論過去及現在,不斷地為學校及個人爭取在學業,運動及各方面的優良成就,從而使我們的母校發光發亮.在學校有需要時,例如校舍擴建籌

toystory

一天，美國總統布殊自豪地對著兒子說：為父為了我們的國家盡心盡力，把我們的國家弄至空前強大…(下刪250讚美自已的字) ，所以你應該繼任總統，你的兒子也應該繼任總統，你的兒子的兒子也應該繼任總統...；轉頭便對兒子的同學說：你也奢望競選總統？你的父母為我們的國家付出或貢獻過些什麼？單憑你們這些張三李四的父母便可使我們的國家強大嗎？跟著便對著一個剛剛亡國的人說：你應該羞恥慚愧，是你們這些廢物把你的國家弄至覆亡的…，接著便和兒子驗血去了，為了証明自已家族的DNA是優良傳統、高人一等…

一天，少林寺代當地政府派米，門外大排長龍，但少林寺優先派給少林弟子，門外的人當然起哄，一個少林弟子走到方丈面前說：我全家都是少林弟子，門外那些不相信及看不起少林寺的人，又想從少林寺手中得到

toystory

一天，董生對著兒子說：為父為了我們的社會盡心盡力，…，所以你應該繼任特首，你的兒子也應該繼任特首，你的兒子的兒子也應該繼任特首，就讓我們家族世世代代成為特首吧！哈..哈..哈..

一覺醒來，原來剛剛造了一個春秋大夢。

toystory

少林寺故事(前傳)：

原來，少林寺故事發生前兩天，門外的人已經因派米專益少林弟子的事而起哄，之後，少林寺各高僧、寺內弟子紛紛出來解說，部份痛心疾首，部份好言相勸，最後，一名高僧更即席唸經文，門外的俗世人的智慧當然不明所以，於是，一人問：究竟這種優先是否公平？

面對這個簡單的問題，眾人竟然默然。

阿十

少林寺代政府派米這故事真有趣,我現在才知原來少林寺真是政府出錢出力去興建,再由各街坊們大聲唱好所以才會有今天的成就.而不是我們這些小僧所知的是少林寺自己籌集資金來建成他們自己的寺院,再由歷代高僧經過多年的建設和維護.
政府要派米自會在自己的糧倉開倉來派,真奇怪點解人們係要去少林寺排隊.少林寺如果真係代政府派米都要少林寺的和尚出力去派.難道阿太妳有份出力幫過手嗎?少林寺的和尚個個自己都唔使食,淨係派俾妳食晒好唔好?眾少林弟子們辛勤工作,耕種和四出傳道,才能普渡眾生.我相信各父母都有母校,但係點解有些人咁抗拒去拿取妳們那10分.自己有屋企唔番係要去爭人

阿十

少林寺代政府派米這故事真有趣,我現在才知原來少林寺真是政府出錢出力去興建,再由各街坊們大聲唱好所以才會有今天的成就.而不是我們這些小僧所知的是少林寺自己籌集資金來建成他們自己的寺院,再由歷代高僧經過多年的建設和維護.
政府要派米自會在自己的糧倉開倉來派,真奇怪點解人們係要去少林寺排隊.少林寺如果真係代政府派米都要少林寺的和尚出力去派.難道阿太妳有份出力幫過手嗎?少林寺的和尚個個自己都唔使食,淨係派俾妳食晒好唔好?眾少林弟子們辛勤工作,耕種和四出傳道,才能普渡眾生.我相信各父母都有母校,但係點解有些人咁抗拒去拿取妳們那10分.自己有屋企唔番係要去爭人

toystory

少林寺果然名不虛傳，教出一個不可一世、目中無人、一語罵盡天下父母的少林弟子，還自稱

阿十

難道各下才是少林弟子,唔係妳點知我真是冒充的呢?天下父母原來只有妳一人,失敬,失敬.請不要將天下父母也等同各下一樣膚淺.不信天父又學人講聖經,不信佛祖又想教人普渡眾生.好在少林弟子中沒有妳這樣有恥之徒,果真是善哉善哉.
有道理請繼續討論,無point請收

HuiTung

My principle of joining this forum is not to involve in any "quarrel" and not to give any feedback if other member disagrees with my point as I respect other people's views.  But this time, someone has mentioned and interpreted my views in a rude manner, trying to make his own points in a high profile way.  I hope this person would repect yourself first before commenting other people's views!!!

I can tell you I won't do such thing in order to get an extra 5 marks.  Moreover, my child is only 2 1/2 years old, how did you know that I had used the "address borrowing tactic"?  Do not think you are a clever person, please.  Everyone is equal here!

toystory

為了不讓無恥之徒一走了之，就跟你雄辯一番：

美國總統和特首跟兒子的一番話是諷刺"世襲制度"和"有貢獻就應有特權"呀，你懂唔懂呀？唉！你卻拿公平競選的美國總統任期制度來跟這個不公平的小一自行收生計分制度比較，還說什麼尊重遊戲規則，若不是偷換概念，便是邏輯混淆。我估你是後者！(有point 就解釋，無point 收工啦。)

至於這故事是否在渲染這制度不公平，看官心裡有數。

就像stccmc說："接受政府每年以千萬計的資助小學, 要求小一入學規則中優待教友又是否合理?"。 那保良局津校可不可以要求入學規則中優待捐助額到一個特定水平的人?(有point 就解釋，無point 收工啦。)

此外，別忘記你所說的超級名校，每年需要接受政府以千萬計的資助，單憑”一

AmyWonglo

Hi, everybody,

I don't think there is any point in arguing the 5 marks for reglious.  Because, if the system doesn't has this mark, I am sure parents will state the reglious on the child's resume to let the school knows.  Therefore, this advantage will still exist if you have the same reglious as the school.  

And please don't think there will be a system which will satisfy every parent.  If there is, I hope it will be the one soon announced.

We all know that if there is no marking system, we will be either forced to put our children in the fate of lottery.  Or, children will need to attend interviews/exams just like those apply to private schools.  Because we want to enjoy for fee education provide by the govt, we will need to follow the rules of the game, no matter you think it is right or not.  Otherwise, you will need to pay high education fee for your children.  This is take it or leave it.  

Right now, because you have only one choice in the first round, it is actually a big gamble on what you choose.  If you fail in the 1st round, you will need to rely on fate.  Why can't we have more choice in the 1st round?  Some people will rise the point regarding "fair game" again.  So, how to be fair to everybody?  If anybody think of any option, please let the govt know.   

The problem is actually in the education system.  Why do we have 5 bands (or 3 bands, I am not sure) of schools?   If all the schools (or most of the schools) in Hong Kong have good reputation, we don't need to worry that much about which school our children go.  Just like McDonald, they have good management in the food supply and how to decorate the stores.  If you want to have McDonld's food, you won't need to think of which one to go, you just need to find the one close to your location because you know that the food supplies in the store will be almost the same standard of the others.  (Maybe, McDonald is not that good in their food for somebody.  The example here is regarding their management.)  If there is a standard of how to be a good school and the schools exist meet the standard (those do not meet the standard will be out of the operation), then, to me that will ease the pressure about which school I should select.   

麟媽媽

stccmc,
唉！名校都梗係”樹大都有枯枝”喇！上星期去見一個客，某大集團的Director，又是一間超級名校畢業生。閒談間講開小兒升小學，佢開始高談闊論佢既擇偶條件，生仔大計！他說搵女朋友要查人背景，讀咩學校，一定要出自名校，話如果生仔就無問題，如果生女無名校讀點算！？見佢真係好反感，唔怪得佢成40歲人都無老婆！

hinhinmummy

昨天去個女的幼稚園畢業禮, 當中有一個項目, 係學校小朋友慕道班的小朋友祈禱.

有兩個小朋友:
其中一段:
男 : 如果小一果班有頑皮的小朋友甘我點算?
女 : 所以我們要求天父給我們大方, 寬恕人的心, 祈禱幫左呢d頑皮, 成績差的小朋友.

大概的意思係甘, 因為不記得exactly, 希望大家能有一顆寬恕別人的心.

KiuKiu媽媽

個標題唔系講緊名校喎, 點解好似離左題咁, 重要長篇大論!!

麟媽媽

Kiukiu媽媽，
只因為大多名校都有宗教背景，大家先咁緊張呢5分，如果係靠呢5分入左長洲間天主教學校，大家唔會開個題目講，你話點會同名校無關係呢？